This isn’t an adequate answer to your question, but I thought that was the last one that had songs that were hits and were played on the same stations that were playing new alternative bands, ect. It has You Don’t Know How It Feels and Wreck Me. Even when I wasn’t “into music yet” I remember You Don’t Know How It Feels as a popular contemporary hit. If that explains anything, it might be that for people who grew up in the ’90s it was the Tom Petty album they actually got into when it was new. It came out right after a Greatest Hits album that had massive sales, which also means that it had the only big hits that weren’t on that comp.
I dunno, I expected Damn the Torpedoes to have the highest ratings.