Index > Has any band had a credible lineup with no original members? (edit regarding my comment on The Brothers) > Renaissance > This and Soft Machine were the two that came to mind (nt) > Different people are answering different questions here

Re: Different people are answering different questions here

Posted by Joe (@joe) on Aug. 12, 2026, 4:04 p.m.

I did say that people could interpret “credible” themselves, but yeah, I did kind of mean something that deserves some respect or has a successful album or something.

Also, echoing the discussion above, Heart is a BS example.